DimensionBeforeDesignLiveWhat we measured
First impression & focusWhat loads, what's covered, what to click
2
9
7
Before: promo modal + cookie banner + chat bubble on load, headline hidden, three H1s and six identical “Shop Now” buttons. Design: opens on photography and product, one H1, two ranked CTAs, no pop-ups. Live: one H1, the concern bar under the nav and no cookie banner or chat bubble — but the hero is a 5-slide carousel that changes every 6 s, each slide with its own button, and a full-screen email pop-up opens about 9 s in.
Navigation & IACan a customer always keep browsing?
3
9
8
Before: header collapses to “HOME” + cart on every product page; four domains. Design: one domain, the same header and footer everywhere, 7-concern bar, breadcrumbs. Live: all of that, plus the grouped phone menu (Collections · Shop by concern · Help). The old addresses (/shop, /about, /faq) answer “page not found” instead of redirecting.
Merchandising & discoveryFinding the right product
2
9
8
Before: “Showing 6 products” of 18, five text links, no filters or sort. Design: all 18, 12 collections, filters, sort, badges, one consistent pack-shot frame. Live: all 18, 12 collections, category counts, concern chips, price slider, sort, badges and add to cart on every card. The reframed pack shots did not ship, so the grid’s framing is uneven again.
Product page conversionThe buy box and what supports it
3
9
8
Before: framework-blue button, truncated description, no related products, reviews, breadcrumb or bundle. Design: gallery, benefits, savings, tiers, subscribe & save, bundle, accordions, sticky add-to-cart. Live: breadcrumb, gallery, price with savings, 1 / 3 / 5-bar tiers, brand button, shipping and returns beside it, ingredients open, a bought-together bundle at −10% and a sticky add-to-cart on phones. Subscribe & save is not live yet.
Trust & social proofReasons to believe, close to the buy button
4
8
3
Before: three static quotes on home; eight real customer videos and a 30-answer FAQ buried; returns policy says 7 days in one place and 30 in another. Design: trust row on the product page, real videos surfaced, one policy, review slots labelled as placeholders. Live: one 30-day policy everywhere and the videos in the main nav — but the “4.8 · 165 reviews” rating and the named, “verified” quotes are the design’s demo content, shown as if real (the product page says so below its rating breakdown, the homepage does not). Scored down until they come off.
Mobile experience390px, thumbs, layout stability
3
9
6
Before: cookie banner covers ~40% of the screen, chat bubble overlaps buttons, store product page shifts as it loads (CLS 1.49). Design: drawer menu, concern bar, bottom-sheet filters, sticky add-to-cart, zoom allowed, CLS 0. Live: grouped drawer, concern bar, sticky add-to-cart and CLS 0 — but pinch-zoom is switched off, the email pop-up fills the phone screen, and the homepage hero takes 10.1 s to paint on a throttled phone.
Brand consistencyType, colour, components across pages
3
9
9
Before: serif brand site vs Lato/system store with a blue #188BF6 button, two headers, two footers. Design: one component library. Live: the design’s three typefaces, header, cards, buy box and footer on every page we checked, with the add-to-cart button in brand ink.
Speed & technical healthRequests, third parties, Core Web Vitals
5
9
4
Before: 11 third-party hosts, mobile LCP 5.3 s (home) and 7.0 s (shop), Best Practices 74–79. Design: one third party, Best Practices 100, mobile LCP 2.0–2.8 s. Live (medians of three, throttled phone): LCP 10.1 s home, 4.6 s shop, 12.8 s product page; pages weigh 2.2–3.5 MB. Card images go out at 2,500 px for a ~280 px slot. Best Practices 74–79: a Shopline app iframe sets third-party cookies. Layout is stable everywhere (CLS 0–0.005).
AccessibilityLighthouse a11y + manual checks
8
9
7
Before: brand site 95–100, store product page 90 (contrast, heading order, tap targets). Design: 100 on every page. Live: Lighthouse 93–94 on every page and device; the failures are pinch-zoom switched off for every visitor and one control whose visible text does not match its accessible name.
OverallMean of 9 dimensions
3.7
8.9
6.7
+3.0 against the old store; −2.2 against the design prototype.